Abstract
The prosecution of past gross human rights violations in Indonesia raises complex legal issues such as non-retroactivity, criminal procedure, command responsibility and transitional justice. This article explores the relationship between the principle of legality and the obligation of the state to ensure accountability for serious violations of human rights . The type of research used is normative legal research with statutory approach, conceptual approach, comparative approach and case approach. The objective of this research is Law No. 26 of 2000 on Human Rights Courts, procedural requirements in historical cases and the standard of establishing individual criminal responsibility. The results indicate that the main obstacles to accountability remain the legal uncertainty of the temporal application of criminal law, procedural difficulties in historical cases and problems in proving command responsibility. The study also finds that criminal proceedings alone cannot address all the consequences of past violations and must be supplemented by truth-seeking, reparations, institutional reform and guaranties of non-recurrence. The article offers an integrated legal framework that links legality, individual responsibility and transitional justice. It is necessary to clarify procedural responsibilities, to improve evidence preservation and investigation, and to better coordinate judicial and non-judicial mechanisms, while protecting legal certainty, fair-trial guaranties and victims’ rights.